Our buyers live and breathe their categories, testing hundreds of products a year so that only the best make it into your box. This season, we asked them to step out from behind the curation process and share the one product they personally cannot stop using. Here are their picks, straight from the experts who chose them.
Teagan Alexander, Senior Buyer – Skincare and Bath & Body
Favorite product in box: MALIN+GOETZ Eau de Parfum, available in Bergamot and Rum
I am a huge MALIN+GOETZ fan, so getting to bring their fragrances into the Fall Box has been a personal highlight for me this season. Bergamot opens with bright grapefruit and bell pepper, settles into warm ginger and cardamom, and dries down into soft musk and sandalwood. It is fresh and energizing, perfect for easing into fall. Rum is the moodier counterpart, with plum and anise up top, leather and vanilla in the heart, and a rich patchouli and amber base that feels cozy and a little sultry. I love that members get to choose the scent that matches their mood. What makes this even more special is that we are able to offer our members a full-size fragrance in a box this season. Fragrance is such a personal, elevated category, and getting to deliver that experience at full size feels like a true win for our members!
Mary Kate McNulty, Assistant Buyer – Fashion, Fitness, Home, and Technology
Favorite product in box: Mali & Lili Faux Suede Tote
The Mali & Lili Faux Suede Tote is my favorite product in the Fall Box because it’s such a timeless staple that instantly elevates any outfit while still feeling effortless. The faux suede texture perfectly captures the cozy essence of Fall and pairs beautifully with any outfit. I also love how spacious and practical it is, it’s the kind of bag you can carry every day, whether you’re heading to work, running errands, or traveling for the weekend. It’s stylish, versatile, and functional, making it a piece I know our members will reach for all season long and beyond!
Olivia Hempstead, Associate Buyer – Fashion & Fitness
Favorite product in box: BUMPSUIT The Cloud Crop Long Sleeve Tee and The Cloud Pant
I am so excited to bring The Cloud Pant and Cloud Crop Long Sleeve Tee to the Fall Box because they truly live up to their name. I’m always on the hunt for pieces that feel just as good as they look, and this set instantly became one of my favorites. The fabric is unbelievably soft with the perfect amount of stretch, and it’s the kind of outfit you’ll want to live in all season long. I love that the relaxed tee and wide-leg pants can be worn together as a matching set or mixed with other wardrobe staples, making them incredibly versatile. It’s the perfect balance of cozy and elevated, and I’m so excited our members get to experience it this fall!
Lily Burrill, Assistant Buyer – Beauty
Favorite product in box: Supergoop! Glowscreen SPF 40, available in Dawn, Sunrise, Golden Hour, and Sunset
I’m a huge fan of Supergoop! and the Glowscreen SPF 40 in Golden Hour has been an amazing step in my beauty routine. I love that it has SPF in it because wearing sunscreen has definitely become a priority for me even in Fall (and Winter!). You can apply it after your skincare routine, and it leaves this effortless glow on your face, which is especially great for the days that you don’t want to wear makeup. But if you do want to wear it under makeup, it’s a perfect base layer and will definitely still give you that glowy, dewy look. With this, you can achieve that summertime glow year-round, and I’m so excited that our members will have the chance to choose this in the Fall 2026 Box!
Yasmine Nassar, Buyer – Home, Fashion, Food & Beverage
Favorite product in box: Williams Sonoma Soup of the Day Cookbook
I love this Soup of the Day Cookbook because it makes cooking feel approachable with simple, flavorful recipes for every season. As I’m beginning my cooking journey, I love trying new recipes and experimenting with different ingredients and techniques. It’s also the perfect fall item, inspiring cozy homemade meals! I can’t wait for our members to be able to bring the cookbook into their kitchen and cook up something delicious!
Lauren Dimitrovski, Senior Buyer – Home
Favorite product in box: Cravings by Chrissy Teigen Marble Condiment Set
Love the brand, so I was super excited when we were able to partner with Chrissy and her team on this gorgeous marble condiment set. The quality is impeccable, the aesthetic is on point, and even my guests love it! Definitely a staple in my kitchen.
Lindsay Chee, Buyer – Hair
Favorite product in box: Earth Harbor CALYPSO Antioxidant Glow Facial Oil
I have sensitive skin, but this oil does not clog pores and is the perfect last step to my skincare routine! I use this every night to help lock in all the benefits from my products. I love that it is made with all-natural ingredients that were chosen so thoughtfully. This has truly helped my skin become so soft, glowy, and hydrated!
Cheyenne Wasyln, Associate Buyer – Beauty
Favorite product in box: Salt & Stone Body Wash, Bergamot & Hinoki
I’m a huge fan of Salt & Stone in general, but I love this body wash! It makes my shower routine feel so elevated, and I’m obsessed with the scent! Definitely going to continue to be a staple in my body wash rotation.
Analise Defaria, Associate Buyer – Beauty
Favorite product in box: R+Co TELEVISION Perfect Hair Shampoo & Conditioner Set
This shampoo and conditioner combo has quickly become one of my favorites! My hair feels so much healthier after using it, and so much volume. It smells incredible too; it’s warm and kind of cozy, not like your typical shampoo smell. I’ve noticed less breakage, and it just looks shinier overall, especially after a blowout. If your hair’s been feeling kind of blah lately, this duo will fix that.
Catherine Casey, Senior Buyer – Fashion
Favorite product in box: Laidrey Double Walled French Press
The French press is a must-have for your kitchen. For me, it not only makes a mean cup of joe, but it also serves as a daily reminder to slow down and enjoy my morning. Instead of just pressing a button on a machine, brewing with a French press is a grounding ritual. Nothing beats a lazy Sunday with it!
Madi Hufnus, Buyer – Wellness
Favorite product in box: Thanks! Naturals Tea Tree Tingle Muscle Freeze Roll-On
The Tea Tree Tingle Muscle Freeze Roll-On has become my post-gym obsession. It’s infused with tea tree, peppermint, and eucalyptus, giving you a cooling, tingly feeling that helps ease muscle tension and soreness. I mostly use it after a tough workout, but my mom swears by it for her joint pain too. The roll-on applies smoothly with no mess, and I love that it’s from a women-owned brand.
From skincare to fragrance to kitchen staples, the Fall 2026 Box has a little something for everyone, straight from the buyers who picked it. Which product is your favorite?
